Booked All Week

and next week, too

The Shorter Novels of Herman Melville: Benito Cereno/Bartleby the Scrivener/The Encantadas/Billy Budd, Foretopman

with 9 comments

Oh, Melville! There was not one story, or novella, in this collection that did not tussle my hair with wind, spritz my skin with salt-spray, or intimidate me with the threatening sound of white-capped waves slapping the side of an old, leaky ship (save Bartleby, which is no less fantastic for it’s relatively mundane setting). I was equally transported by each, across a world of land and sea.

In Benito Cereno, our narrator witnesses a strange vessel rush to the shore of a vacant island with sails tattered and flapping. The mysterious craft looks in no shape to start trouble, so he boards with the intention of lending a helping hand. But something seems…off, with both the evasive captain and the menacing crew. I liked the way the narrator flip-flops in his interpretation of what’s going on: his discovery is not a slow dawning of the truth, but a constant interrogation of bizarre surroundings. Sadly, but fittingly for Melville’s time and place, this story is heavy on Heart of Darkness-style racism  which is used to play up the unsettling tone of the story and the savagery of past events aboard ship, intermittently revealed. Nevertheless, it’s tied up in a manner I found quite satisfying. The final paragraphs pack a creepy, powerful punch!

It’s slightly shameful that it has taken me so long to read the second story, Bartleby the Scrivener, since I’ve watched the movie adaptation with Crispin Glover a number of times already and am not at all opposed to watching it again.* In Melville’s original, it’s startling how quickly Bartleby begins to issue his “I’d prefer not to”s, and how earnestly his boss works to understand his employee’s refusal to do, well, anything. He really tries to get into Bartleby’s head, and feels a genuine sympathy for him, imagining how such a person could make it so far in life, and what such a life must entail. What could make a person so obstinate, so anti-authoritarian, so disruptive to simple bureaucracy by his very temperament and presence?

The third, The Encantadas, was my favorite. It’s almost out of place, as it doesn’t contain a standard, cohesive narrative. It’s a portrait of a place, a sketch of the many enchanted isles that make up the cluster known for misleading lost crews. It’s a place where compass needles spin wildly and ghost ships appear and disappear into the mist. A place where people have never lived that draws them in with the hunger of a bottomless stomach. One that doesn’t show up on maps, but is legend to all who’ve spent time at sea. Some micro-histories of sea-faring fellows’ contact with the islands are provided, a sort of warning about nature’s imperviousness to human willpower, an environment that promises eternal exploration and unknowing.

The last novella, Billy Budd, might have held the least pull for me, but only just so. Billy is a handsome and extremely popular sailer born of low means and conscripted into service. For all but the captain, he is a golden child and can do no wrong. But the captain disdains him and, with a paranoia likely mirroring the real feelings of captains at the time following true and recent mutinous events, accuses him of organizing against him. In a frustrating confrontation, Billy accidentally kills Captain Claggart, and despite everyone else’s conviction that he is a good man and didn’t mean to, they are committed to upholding The Law. I like the contradiction here between what is legal and what is right, though after having heard inferences of a gay subtext in this plot I was a little disappointed that I couldn’t much make it out. Or, maybe I have, but I’m not sure about it. Is it that the descriptions of Billy as handsome and perfect imply desirability amongst an all male crew? Is it that Claggart hates him in the way school kids hate on their crushes, and kills that impulse by causing his downfall? I know this is only one reading of the text, but it’s a popular one, right? I think I might need to read this one more closely, or seek out a critical essay or something about it.

As I’ve hopefully made obvious, I thoroughly enjoyed my first encounter with Melville…much more than I expected to. I never truly considered that I would before, but I’ll be damned if that taste of his work hasn’t inclined me toward taking a stab at Moby Dick some day.

*Bartleby is now streaming on Netflix! It is weird and fun and the set is in the style of that town in Edward Scissorhands, and Crispin is great as Bartleby, so consider this a recommendation (but it is weird, so I’ll be sorry if you do take this recommendation and then hate it, as both my mom and brother have done. Oops :/)

Written by Emily Jane

November 5, 2012 at 5:45 am

9 Responses

Subscribe to comments with RSS.

  1. This may not affect your decision at all, but I will say: I loved Bartleby the Scrivener (the only short fiction of Melville’s I’ve read so far) and hated Moby Dick with a passion. I think there is an argument to be made for reading Moby Dick as long as you are comfortable skimming over long swathes of book when it gets started talking about whaling. There’s a really good novel under all the


    November 6, 2012 at 12:34 am

    • Hm. This posted before I was ready. I was going to say a really good novel under all the blubber, a joke I am now reconsidering because it is so extremely silly. :p


      November 6, 2012 at 12:37 am

      • Haha, I like the joke 🙂 Hmmm I am definitely one of those readers that can’t skim or skip over anything EVER no matter how much I might be tempted, so I’ll have to consider that. On the other hand, I really liked all those long segments of Anna Karenina that are just about farming technique and bored everyone else, so maybe it would be okay? Only time will tell! (If I do try it, it won’t be for a looooong time probably).

        Emily Jane

        November 6, 2012 at 12:45 am

  2. I only know of Moby Dick.

  3. I ve read moby dick but not these ,if you doI suggest the phillp heshner book about whales and whaling at same time they’d work great together so much info in the heshner that make moby dick clear ,,I have typee by him to read at some point I picked up second hand ,all the best stu


    November 7, 2012 at 5:43 pm

    • Great suggestion, Stu, thanks! If/when I pick up Moby Dick, I’d love to pair it with that.

      Emily Jane

      December 3, 2012 at 10:47 pm

  4. I just read a great queer interpretation of Billy Budd in David Halperin’s HOW TO BE GAY: basically, Billy is so attractive that everyone is kind of in love with him and does things for him; he’s the “ideal one-night stand” (215) who isn’t all that smart or interesting but is nice to look at. He’s innocent and empty-headed, compared to a pet, and when trouble arises, he becomes even more beautiful because of his martyrdom and his ability to be remembered as beautiful without having to actually deal with the feelings he arouses.


    November 10, 2012 at 9:02 pm

    • Just what I was looking for, Cass! Might have to check that one out. Thanks!

      Emily Jane

      December 3, 2012 at 10:47 pm

      • I hope you do, it’s suuuuuuch a good read.


        December 4, 2012 at 9:49 pm

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: